So below is our pair of seed lists. We have one for a UAB victory (UAB as a 13) and one for a Temple victory (Temple as a 15). I think that the Big Ten finalists will hold their positions regardless of result.
Where did we struggle? First, on Duke v Auburn for the last 3. Very close call for us, but while Duke didn't help themselves (at all), Auburn didn't beat anyone ahead of or level with them (say, Alabama, Tennessee, or Kentucky) so it wasn't quite enough to move them up a line.
Second, on Clemson. I don't think they deserve the 6 I gave them, but their profile just looked better than the 7's. Speaking of which, we had trouble sorting the Mountain West middle teams. I won't be surprised if USU ends up a 6 or Boise an 8, but we decided to level them all off at 7.
Third, on Washington State. Really, every time I looked at their profile, I saw the two Arizona wins and... not much else. If they end up higher than an 8, we'll know what got them there.
Fourth, TAMU, with their unimpressive overall record and Q3 losses... and all those Q1 games and wins, especially the big ones. I feel like they deserved to be rewarded for the schedule and the wins more than punished for the losses.
I honestly didn't think it was much of a decision at the cut line, and while FAU and Oklahoma didn't really impress me, I'll be shocked if St. John's gets in ahead of them. They're not leaving Michigan State out, and while Colorado lacks quality wins, they avoided the bad losses.
We mostly stuck to the NET rankings for the 12's to 16's. We'll learn from that one way or the other.
Here's the lists:
Seed List (UAB wins) Conference
- CONNECTICUT Big East
- Houston Big 12
- Purdue Big Ten
- North Carolina ACC
- Arizona Pac-12
- Tennessee SEC
- IOWA STATE Big 12
- Marquette Big East
- Creighton Big East
- Baylor Big 12
- Illinois Big Ten
- Duke ACC
- Auburn SEC
- Kentucky SEC
- Alabama SEC
- Kansas Big 12
- BYU Big 12
- San Diego State Mountain West
- South Carolina SEC
- Wisconsin Big Ten
- Texas Tech Big 12
- Florida SEC
- Clemson ACC
- ST. MARY'S West Coast
- Utah State Mountain West
- Gonzaga West Coast
- Nevada Mountain West
- Boise State Mountain West
- Dayton Atlantic 10
- Nebraska Big Ten
- Texas Big 12
- Washington State Pac-12
- Colorado State Mountain West
- Mississippi State SEC
- TCU Big 12
- Northwestern Big Ten
- Texas A&M SEC
- NEW MEXICO Mountain West
- Colorado Pac 12
- Michigan State Big Ten
- Florida Atlantic American
- Oklahoma Big 12
- DRAKE Missouri Valley
- OREGON Pac-12
- NORTH CAROLINA STATE ACC
- GRAND CANYON WAC
- JAMES MADISON Sun Belt
- MCNEESE STATE Southland
- YALE Ivy
- SAMFORD Southern
- DUQUESNE Atlantic 10
- COLLEGE OF CHARLESTON Coastal
- VERMONT America East
- UAB American
- MOREHEAD STATE Ohio Valley
- AKRON MAC
- COLGATE Patriot
- OAKLAND Horizon
- SOUTH DAKOTA STATE Summit
- WESTERN KENTUCKY CUSA
- LONGWOOD Big South
- LONG BEACH STATE Big West
- ST. PETER'S Metro Atlantic
- MONTANA STATE Big Sky
- STETSON Atlantic Sun
- HOWARD MEAC
- GRAMBLING SWAC
- WAGNER Northeast
- CONNECTICUT Big East
- Houston Big 12
- Purdue Big Ten
- North Carolina ACC
- Arizona Pac-12
- Tennessee SEC
- IOWA STATE Big 12
- Marquette Big East
- Creighton Big East
- Baylor Big 12
- Illinois Big Ten
- Duke ACC
- Auburn SEC
- Kentucky SEC
- Alabama SEC
- Kansas Big 12
- BYU Big 12
- San Diego State Mountain West
- South Carolina SEC
- Wisconsin Big Ten
- Texas Tech Big 12
- Florida SEC
- Clemson ACC
- ST. MARY'S West Coast
- Utah State Mountain West
- Gonzaga West Coast
- Nevada Mountain West
- Boise State Mountain West
- Dayton Atlantic 10
- Nebraska Big Ten
- Texas Big 12
- Washington State Pac-12
- Colorado State Mountain West
- Mississippi State SEC
- TCU Big 12
- Northwestern Big Ten
- Texas A&M SEC
- NEW MEXICO Mountain West
- Colorado Pac 12
- Michigan State Big Ten
- Florida Atlantic American
- Oklahoma Big 12
- DRAKE Missouri Valley
- OREGON Pac-12
- NORTH CAROLINA STATE ACC
- GRAND CANYON WAC
- JAMES MADISON Sun Belt
- MCNEESE STATE Southland
- YALE Ivy
- SAMFORD Southern
- DUQUESNE Atlantic 10
- COLLEGE OF CHARLESTON Coastal
- VERMONT America East
- MOREHEAD STATE Ohio Valley
- AKRON MAC
- COLGATE Patriot
- OAKLAND Horizon
- SOUTH DAKOTA STATE Summit
- TEMPLE American
- WESTERN KENTUCKY Conference USA
- LONGWOOD Big South
- LONG BEACH STATE Big West
- ST. PETER'S Metro Atlantic
- MONTANA STATE Big Sky
- STETSON Atlantic Sun
- HOWARD MEAC
- GRAMBLING SWAC
- WAGNER Northeast